Hey friends, Vincent here. Something interesting happened this week that shines a light on how ballot access works in New Jersey. Secretary of State Dale Caldwell filed a brief supporting restoration of Libertarian candidate Leguía to the NJ-7 ballot while simultaneously rejecting her legal motion, citing state law and fairness.
This directly parallels what happened to me in June. Secretary Caldwell reversed Administrative Law Judge Catherine Tuohy's ruling that would have kept me on the NJ-11 printed ballot, removing me on June 11th despite the judge's initial decision in my favor.
These cases highlight the uphill climb unaffiliated and third-party candidates have in a two-party system. If you want more choice, this needs to change.
A Pattern in Caldwell's Ballot Reasoning
What makes the Leguía case particularly relevant is that it establishes a clear pattern in how Secretary Caldwell approaches ballot access decisions. In both cases, we see the same official overturning a judge's ruling and making unilateral determinations about who belongs on the ballot based on his interpretation of state law and what he considers fair to voters.
The parallel is striking. In my case, Caldwell overruled a judge who had found my petition valid. In the Leguía case, he's telling a different judge that she should be restored to the ballot, even while not supporting her specific legal arguments. The common thread appears to be Caldwell's view of what serves the public interest in competitive races.
What This Means for Independent Candidates
As someone who knows how government works and where it doesn't, I can tell you that these decisions matter beyond any single race. They set precedents for how independent and third-party candidates are treated in New Jersey's electoral system.
I take full responsibility for the technical error in my petition that gave Caldwell grounds to remove me. My self-designed nominating petition omitted mandatory pledge language.
But the broader question remains: how do we ensure that ballot access rules are applied consistently and fairly across all races and all candidates? When the same official makes different calls in similar situations, voters deserve to understand the reasoning.
Running as a Write-In Candidate
While I'm no longer on the printed ballot, I'm still running hard as a write-in candidate for NJ-11. Voters who want a Common Sense Independent choice can write "Vincent Matrisciano" exactly as spelled on their ballot this November.
I am controlled by you, not by party bosses or special interests. That independence means I can focus on the practical solutions our district needs: making housing more affordable, fixing our healthcare system, and bringing common sense back to how government operates.
The Leguía case reminds us that ballot access decisions have real consequences for voter choice. Whether you're in NJ-7 or NJ-11, whether you're a Libertarian, Democrat, Republican, or independent like me, every qualified candidate should have a fair shot at making their case to voters.
Read more about my stance on this and other topics concerning the NJ-11
The Issues Chip in to the campaign